Goalkeepers
Manuel Almunia - 75 - All the goalkeepers we have are not top quality so are low, Manuel is on the decrease too
Lukasz Fabianski - 77 - Best we have in terms of progress for age, consitency is an issue
Wojcech Szczesny - 75 - It's generous but he is our no1, player growth should allow for high 80's at his peak
Vito Mannone - 76 - I rate him really high coz he has raw talent
James Shea - 62
Right Backs
Bacary Sagna - 83 - This is not a high number I see no problems, comparisons eg. Rafael 79 Ivanovic 81 Johnson 82
Emmanuel Eboue - 78 - At RWB 78 at RM 79 at RW 78 at CDM 77, Eboue lacks the quality to hit 80's
Gavin Hoyte - 64 - He kept out Calderon 62 of Brighton last season, Green 59 of Lincoln this year
Centre Backs
Thomas Vermaelen - 84 - Our best defender, comparisons eg. Vidic 87 Terry 86 Toure 83
Laurent Koscielny - 80 - A good defender, comparisons eg. Cahill 81 Upson 80 Huth 78
Johan Djourou - 80
Sebastien Squillaci - 78 - Consistent but just not that good at all, I think 78 is generous
Kyle Bartley - 70 - First team for Sheffield Utd
Thomas Cruise - 64 - At LB 64 at LWB 62 he challenged places against of Murphy 64 Carlisle
Ignasi Miquel - 63 - Huge potential should be able to have massive growth
Nico Yennaris - 57
Left Backs
Gael Clichy - 82 - 83 at LWB, his pace is second only to Walcott at Arsenal, comparisons eg. Cole 83 Evra 84
Keiran Gibbs - 78 - At LWB 79 He may be injury prone but will be great
Armand Traore - 74 - At LWB 75 at LM 75 at LW 74, can't break in anywhere but was good at Portsmouth
Pedro Botelho - 64 - At LWB 65 at LM 64 at LW 65
Defensive Midfielders
Alexandre Song - 81 - Still young, big future, comparisons eg. Essien 84 De Jong 80 Fellaini 81
Emmanuel Frimpong - 70 - Last year he was great shame about the knee injury this year
Craig Eastmond - 67 - Straight in the Millwall side
Francis Coquelin - 67 - His Lorient loan was great for him
Central Midfielders
Abou Diaby - 79 - At CDM 78
Aaron Ramsey - 78 - Before his injury possibly better than a 78, comparisons eg. Holden 77 Rodwell 78
Jack Wilshere - 79 - He can pass, shoot, run and tackle perhaps 79 is high though, At CDM 77 at CAM 78
Denilson - 75 - probably 90's in the short passing department, At CDM 74
Henri Lansbury - 70 - At RW 72 at RM 70
Mark Randall - 63
Chuks Aneke - 59 - At CAM 61
Offensive Midfielders
Cesc Fabregas - 87 - Comparisons eg. Lampard 86 Gerrard 85 Xavi 87 Iniesta 88
Tomas Rosicky - 82 - On the decline, At RW 82
Samuel Galindo - 65
Wingers
Samir Nasri - 85 - At CAM 84
Andrei Arshavin - 84 - Declining with good form he could be better
Theo Walcott - 82
Sanchez Watt - 71 - First team for Leeds
Connor Henderson - 58
Strikers
Robin Van Persie - 86 - At RW 84
Marouane Chamakh - 83
Nicklas Bendtner - 80 - At RW 78
Carlos Vela - 78 - On the real peripheries of the team, so close, At LW 78
Jay Emmanuel-Thomas - 73 - Could be the next big thing, At LW 72 at CAM 70 at CDM 67 at LB 68
Gilles Sunu - 66 - His Derby loan was productive but since he has only been good for France
Benik Afobe - 62
Rhys Murphy - 63
Luke Freeman - 60
Wellington Silva - 70 - He has really quick feet
Ryo Miyachi - 66 - At RW 66
Hope I get lots of feedback
ps this message took about an hour and the compiling a few months so EA sports I hope to get some feedback from you guys too|||Why should Song be made worse? I feel he is underrated in the game. Should be 83+. He should be increased in skills such as short passing, ball control, vision etc. Fabianski should be 80, and Djourou should be 81.
Koscielny should only be 79 and rosicky should stay as he is. Arshavin should decrease to 82 and Nasri up to 86.
|||
Why should Song be made worse? I feel he is underrated in the game. Should be 83+. He should be increased in skills such as short passing, ball control, vision etc. Fabianski should be 80, and Djourou should be 81.
Koscielny should only be 79 and rosicky should stay as he is. Arshavin should decrease to 82 and Nasri up to 86.
Yeah I probably would have Song 82 or 83 and the goalkeepers higher|||Your ratings seem pretty fair to me (i'm also an avid arsenal fan), but i would adjust them slightly.
Goalkeepers
Manuel Almunia - 74
Lukasz Fabianski - 78
Wojcech Szczesny - 76
Vito Mannone - 70
James Shea - 62
Right Backs
Bacary Sagna - 83
Emmanuel Eboue - 77
Gavin Hoyte - 64
Centre Backs
Thomas Vermaelen - 84
Laurent Koscielny - 80
Johan Djourou - 82
Sebastien Squillaci - 76
Kyle Bartley - 70
Thomas Cruise - 62 (is he not a fullback?)
Ignasi Miquel - 63
Nico Yennaris - 57
Left Backs
Gael Clichy - 81
Keiran Gibbs - 79
Armand Traore - 75
Pedro Botelho - 64
Defensive Midfielders
Alexandre Song - 83
Emmanuel Frimpong - 70
Craig Eastmond - 67
Francis Coquelin - 67
Central Midfielders
Abou Diaby - 78
Aaron Ramsey - 79
Jack Wilshere - 81
Denilson - 74
Henri Lansbury - 72
Mark Randall - 63
Chuks Aneke - 59
Offensive Midfielders
Cesc Fabregas - 87
Tomas Rosicky - 80
Samuel Galindo - 65
Wingers
Samir Nasri - 85
Andrei Arshavin - 84
Theo Walcott - 82
Sanchez Watt - 71
Connor Henderson - 58
Strikers
Robin Van Persie - 86
Marouane Chamakh - 83
Nicklas Bendtner - 79
Carlos Vela - 76
Jay Emmanuel-Thomas - 73
Gilles Sunu - 66
Benik Afobe - 62
Rhys Murphy - 63
Luke Freeman - 60
Wellington Silva - 67
Ryo Miyachi - 74|||
Nicklas Bendtner - 80 - At RW 78
:)
|||There is no way that Bendtner and Rosicky should be over 80...
and Watt doesn't start at Leeds, he comes in off the bench, and i think his current 68 rating is fine.|||My mistake with Watt, 12 starts + 6 subs on is his current Leeds record, knocking 1-3 off seems fine to me, its the ability for him to improve to 71 in his first season and beyond in subsequent that I would like to personally have.
Bendtner can have 1+ off if hitting the 80 figure brands him differently. Bendtner could be compared with doyle 80 carew 80 or maybe they're all too high.
Rosicky is in a slump period of form, performances and goals perhaps below 80 is what he is now but not his true level.
Good to see a few comments, thanks and keep em coming.
PS we beat barca
just nice to say really|||Imo Vermaelen is a better all round deffender than vidic when ever villa play arsenal Verm. is one of the few deffenders in the league that can contain Aggy's pace where as vidic resorts to pulling him down everytime aggy's on the ball|||
My mistake with Watt, 12 starts + 6 subs on is his current Leeds record, knocking 1-3 off seems fine to me, its the ability for him to improve to 71 in his first season and beyond in subsequent that I would like to personally have.
Bendtner can have 1+ off if hitting the 80 figure brands him differently. Bendtner could be compared with doyle 80 carew 80 or maybe they're all too high.
Rosicky is in a slump period of form, performances and goals perhaps below 80 is what he is now but not his true level.
Good to see a few comments, thanks and keep em coming.
PS we beat barca
just nice to say really
Hey, no problem.
a couple other things i noticed:
Aaron Ramsey- have we really seen enough from him this year to warrant any change in his rating?
and the same with Vermaelen, no doubting the guy is class but he's been injured for so long now, who's to say he's better now then when the game came out?|||I think as far as Vermaelen goes, maybe don't adjust his rating, just give him the injury prone trait. Every time he seems to be coming back, it flairs up again.
I like what I saw out of Koscielny against Barcelona, by far his best effort for Arsenal, but I don't think he's done enough all year to reach 80 quite yet. Maybe up 1 or 2 to 77, 78 tops.
Djourou up to 79, still keep his injury prone trait though.
I like Szczesny up to around 74-75.
Gibbs at 79? I don't think quite yet. He will be but not quite there.
Rosicky is a weird case. He's got quality, but can't seem to put it together for Arsenal, hasn't scored in ages, and probably warrants a drop of 1-2 points.
Nasri up to 86 sounds right.
Bendtner...what is everyone loving about him? Every game he gets put on and every game he fails, often epic-ly. I know Wenger constantly plays him out of position on the wing, but he finds himself inside with chances regularly and sometimes completely misses the ball. Hopefully Arsenal get rid of him this summer, give Chamakh and Vela the chances to back up RVP.|||rosicky shouldn't be higher than 80. whenever he plays he has little to no good influence.
Song should be 84 he is the be DM in the prem at the moment. his strength on the ball is incredible and he tackles well.
Wilshere should be at least 81 he can pick a pass and make great runs through the middle
Fabianski has done great and hasnt made mistake this season so far. he should be 81
szcenzy (or however you spell it) should be 80. a great young goal keeper top 5 in prem at least.
other than that i think it's all good|||The Ramsey case is interesting he is currently 76 i believe, that seems harsh to drop points, perhaps raising points is biased of me too.
Rosicky should be in the 80s imo, however the individual statistic of consistency could be low 20-40 perhaps that might be a good idea
Vermaelen at 84 is what he was at last year and i see no reason to change that - as for injury prone, not so sure he is prone to injuries just one and its been difficult to analyse it as recurring just tautness in the achilles
Gibbs I may have been overzealous with i he not as good as Eboue who I have at 78 maybe 77-8 for gibbs is better
I have underdone Song too but 84 seems high 82 is what he is atm 83 then
Finally Goalkeepers
Almunia - 76 - worse each day
Fabianski - 79 - thats the highest i'll go
Szczesny - 77 - better each day
Mannone - 74 - perhaps too generous first time around
Shea - 62 - +1 optional for trial and loan chance at the saints
Thanks for the comments keep em coming and maybe we'll find a parity and i'll re-post a new thread with the new numbers up and more youngsters
|||
Imo Vermaelen is a better all round deffender than vidic when ever villa play arsenal Verm. is one of the few deffenders in the league that can contain Aggy's pace where as vidic resorts to pulling him down everytime aggy's on the ball
I'm an arsenal fan, but really|||
szcenzy (or however you spell it) should be 80. a great young goal keeper top 5 in prem at least.
He might be in 3-4 years time but right now, he's behind Cech, Reina, van Der Saar, Gomes, Hart, Given & Howard
No comments:
Post a Comment